Proper Nouns And Pronounce
on
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
Posted by
Rajesh J Advani
Here I am, breaking my year and half long self-imposed Maun Vrat (Oath of silence?), to do what I love doing more than anything else.
Complain.
Some things never change, eh?
A friend of mine, often pronounces certain wordswrongly differently from what I consider the correct pronunciation, and refuses to correct herself when I point this out, because she says
A-hem. No, no, not that one! I mean like the sound you make when clearing your throat. Of course, that's more like Ghhmhhmghm, but I digress.
So, where was I? Right.
A-hem. No, you cannot pronounce proper nouns however you want!
Take the case of a name, like 'Rajesh' (that's my name, in case you were wondering). My name has a specific pronunciation, and pronouncing it "Rahash" - "j" is pronounced "h" in spanish/latin/mexican - would be wrong.
Similarly, it is not okay to pronounce the Indian name Dhillon, as "Dhee-yo-n", even if Quesadilla is pronounced as "Ke-sa-dee-ya". "Amit" is "A-mih-t", and cannot be pronounced "A-mite" or "Aim-it". "Iraq" if pronounced "Eye-Rack", is being pronounced wrong, even if it's being pronounced by the President of the United States of America!
Names derived from new additions to the English language are all the more problematic, since you often see the words in print long before you actually hear them. The "Wiki" in Wikipedia, is pronounced "Wih-key", not "Why-key". (On a related note, if you do decide to use the term "LOL" in real speech, then it's pronounced "Ell-oh-Ell", not "Lole"! Of course, I would recommend actually laughing instead.)
A proper noun is a name, and mangling someone's or something's name is not polite - to say the least.
So, the next time any of you decide to change the pronunciation of any so-called "Proper Noun", do consider taking the permission of the owner of that name.
Complain.
Some things never change, eh?
A friend of mine, often pronounces certain words
You can pronounce proper nouns however you want.
A-hem. No, no, not that one! I mean like the sound you make when clearing your throat. Of course, that's more like Ghhmhhmghm, but I digress.
So, where was I? Right.
A-hem. No, you cannot pronounce proper nouns however you want!
Take the case of a name, like 'Rajesh' (that's my name, in case you were wondering). My name has a specific pronunciation, and pronouncing it "Rahash" - "j" is pronounced "h" in spanish/latin/mexican - would be wrong.
Similarly, it is not okay to pronounce the Indian name Dhillon, as "Dhee-yo-n", even if Quesadilla is pronounced as "Ke-sa-dee-ya". "Amit" is "A-mih-t", and cannot be pronounced "A-mite" or "Aim-it". "Iraq" if pronounced "Eye-Rack", is being pronounced wrong, even if it's being pronounced by the President of the United States of America!
Names derived from new additions to the English language are all the more problematic, since you often see the words in print long before you actually hear them. The "Wiki" in Wikipedia, is pronounced "Wih-key", not "Why-key". (On a related note, if you do decide to use the term "LOL" in real speech, then it's pronounced "Ell-oh-Ell", not "Lole"! Of course, I would recommend actually laughing instead.)
A proper noun is a name, and mangling someone's or something's name is not polite - to say the least.
So, the next time any of you decide to change the pronunciation of any so-called "Proper Noun", do consider taking the permission of the owner of that name.
8 comments:
Welcome back :)
Damn!!!! Thats a really loooong time my friend!!! Welcome back.....you were nearly out of my RSS reader!!
@anantha: Thanks for not forgetting me!
@deaths head roy: Yep, a reaaallly long time. And I'm glad I made it back before you clicked delete :) I get the feeling, though, that a number of other people might have purged me from their feed readers by now :)
Wow! Nice to see you come back...I started reading your blog arnd the time you "Paused" :)
Looking forward to read your work:)
This is a problem I see here. Some of my colleagues used to make fun of me for the same reason, that I pronounce it the way we were taught to pronounce, and they in a different way. "Anti" pronounced as "Ant-Eye", etc. And its said to be American English.
lol..
i am pronouncing it as ell-o-ell
ofcourse i would rather prefer laughing myself.. but u can't listen to it naa
Hiii, this is an interesting topic. I remember one foreigner who pronounced Ram and the aries the ram, and it was so embarrasing for her...
Haiku Poems
Just wanted to say thank you for writing this. I was trying to prove this exact point to someone I knew and this hit the nail right on the head. Great post!
Post a Comment